The holidays in Kansas City wouldn’t be complete without a show-stopping pie at the center of your table. Skip the last-minute grocery store dash and the stress of baking; the Corner Cafe has your dessert menu handled. We’ve selected a list that will make your holiday dessert decision the easiest one all season. If you’re looking for the absolute best, the Corner Cafe’s bakery is here to deliver just that with a collection of Kansas City’s most beloved pies, perfect for gifting, gathering, or simply savoring.
Our Top Picks for Holiday Pies in Kansas City
We know what you’re thinking: “best pie” is a strong claim. But trust us, we’ve done the delicious legwork. Our selection focuses on the legendary pies that consistently earn rave reviews and disappear fastest at every holiday gathering across Kansas City and beyond. These aren’t just good pies; they’re experiences available by the slice or whole pie.
Classic Apple Pie
When it comes to apple pie, we believe in tradition done right. Our top pick features a mountain of fresh apples baked to tender perfection, perfectly spiced with cinnamon and a hint of nutmeg, all nestled under a golden, flaky, butter-rich crust. It’s the kind of pie that reminds you of grandma’s kitchen, with just the right balance of sweetness and spice to bring out that homemade magic. This isn’t just an apple pie; it’s a warm, comforting hug in edible form.
Decadent Pecan Pie
For those who appreciate the finer things, our pecan pie is an absolute must. Imagine a rich, buttery filling, deeply caramelized, studded with a generous layer of plump, toasted pecans. The crust is delicate, providing the perfect counterpoint to the gooey, nutty center. It’s not overly sweet; instead, it strikes a sophisticated balance that lets the natural, earthy flavor of the pecans shine through. This pie is a showstopper, a true dessert that steals the show and satisfies even the most discerning palate. It’s elegance, simplified.
Pumpkin Pie—A Fall Classic
You simply can’t have the holidays without a truly exceptional pumpkin pie. Our take on this autumn essential features a silky-smooth, perfectly spiced pumpkin, rich with notes of cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and a whisper of allspice. It’s baked to perfection in a crisp, slightly sweet crust that holds its own against the creamy filling. The texture is key here—velvety and melt-in-your-mouth, never watery or dense. It’s the quintessential taste of fall, a familiar comfort that tastes like home. Topped with a dollop of whipped cream, it’s the taste of fall in every bite.
No-Sugar-Added Pies
We believe everyone deserves a seat at the table, which is why we offer fantastic no-sugar-added options. Don’t mistake “no sugar added” for “no flavor.” Our bakers craft these pies with the same dedication to taste and quality, using natural sweetness from fruits or alternative sweeteners to ensure a delightful experience. Currently, our no-sugar-added chocolate and coconut cream pies are crowd favorites, offering all the joy of a classic with thoughtful considerations for dietary needs. It’s proof that health-conscious can still be incredibly delicious.
Why Our Pies Are the Talk of the Town
Our pies don’t just happen; they’re the result of passion, precision, and a deep understanding of what makes a truly unforgettable dessert. We’ve honed our craft, ensuring that every single pie leaving our kitchen meets the highest standards of quality and taste.
Hand-Crafted with Love
We start with the finest ingredients: real butter for our flaky crusts, fresh local produce when available, and premium spices. Our bakers aren’t just following recipes; they’re artists, meticulously rolling dough, perfectly blending fillings, and gently crimping edges with a care that you can taste in every bite. It’s this personal touch, this dedication to the craft, that elevates our pies from mere desserts to edible works of art.
The Spice of Life
They say that “variety is the spice of life,” and we’ve got spice in spades—by the slice or whole pie! In addition to the fall selections mentioned above, we’ve also got a daily assortment of classic cream pies (chocolate, coconut cream, and banana), lemon meringue pie (only available on Fridays), and even a dessert of the day. These tempting baked goods are available by the slice or whole pie, and available for pickup or delivery. We can also cover your holiday breakfast or special occasion with a pack of our famous homemade cinnamon rolls for pickup or delivery!
How to Order Your Holiday Pies
Securing your holiday pies should be as enjoyable as eating them. We’ve streamlined our ordering process to be as straightforward and convenient as possible, ensuring you can focus on holiday cheer, not holiday stress.
Online Ordering Made Easy
Our user-friendly website is designed for a seamless ordering experience. Simply browse our delectable selection, add your chosen pies to your cart, and proceed to checkout. You’ll receive an immediate confirmation, giving you peace of mind that your holiday dessert is taken care of. It’s easy, quick, and open around the clock.
Pre-Order Deadlines
To guarantee the freshest pies and accommodate the high holiday demand, we strongly encourage pre-ordering. Our pre-order deadlines for Thanksgiving are typically two weeks prior to the holiday, and for Christmas, it’s usually around December 21. We’ll announce exact dates on our website and social media, so keep an eye out! Placing your order early ensures your pie will be ready when you need it. Additionally, we make extra pies the day before Thanksgiving, and anything not picked up by 6 pm is sold on a first come, first served basis!
Pick-Up and Delivery Options
We offer convenient pick-up from our Kansas City location during designated hours leading up to the holidays. For those within a specific radius, we also provide a limited delivery service* for a small fee, bringing the magic right to your doorstep so you can spend less time in the kitchen and more time making memories. All options will be clearly detailed during the checkout process.
*Please note that we turn off bakery options from Door Dash the week of Thanksgiving.
Frequently Asked Questions About Our Holiday Pies
We understand you might have a few questions before making your selection. Here are some of the most common inquiries we receive:
Can I customize my pie order?
While we pride ourselves on our classic recipes, we do not offer extensive customization for individual pie orders, especially during peak holiday seasons. Our focus is on perfecting our core offerings to ensure consistency and quality.
What’s the best way to store my pie?
Most of our fruit pies and our pecan pie are best stored at room temperature for up to three days. Banana and pumpkin pies have a 2-day holding time in refrigeration, and all other cream pies have a 3-day holding time in refrigeration. Specific storage instructions will be provided with your order.
Can I pick up my order on Thanksgiving/Christmas Day?
To allow our team to enjoy the holidays with their families, we are closed on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day. All holiday pie pickups are scheduled for the days leading up to these holidays. The last pick-up time for Thanksgiving is the Wednesday before by 6 pm, and the last pick-up time for Christmas is December 24 by 1 pm (we close at 3 pm on Christmas Eve). Please refer to the pick-up schedule provided to you during the ordering process.
Can I order a Corner Cafe gift card?
Yes! We sell gift cards that make a wonderful host or hostess gift during the holidays. Select your desired amount and choose between a digital gift card that can be printed with a personal message, or a physical gift card that will be sent via mail. Physical gift cards can be customized with a personal message and should arrive within 7-10 days for standard delivery.
Get Your Holiday Pie Today!
Don’t let the holidays catch you unprepared. Elevate your celebration with truly exceptional, delicious pies from the heart of the Midwest. Your guests (and your taste buds!) will thank you. Head to our online bake shop now and secure your slice of holiday heaven. Ready to reserve your slice of holiday heaven? Order online today, or contact our friendly team at any of our three convenient locations in Riverside, Liberty, or Independence, Missouri.
